FORE Magazine

Top Menu

  • About Me
  • Contact Us
  • Home

Main Menu

  • Current Issue
  • Digital Book
  • Profiles
  • Sustainability
  • Travel
  • 19th Hole
  • Classic Course
  • FORE Her
  • More
    • Know the Rules
    • Handicap Hints
    • SCGA Junior
    • Where Are They Now?
    • News
    • Public Affairs
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login

logo

FORE Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Digital Book
  • Profiles
  • Sustainability
  • Travel
  • 19th Hole
  • Classic Course
  • FORE Her
  • More
    • Know the Rules
    • Handicap Hints
    • SCGA Junior
    • Where Are They Now?
    • News
    • Public Affairs
Fall 2017Know the Rules
Home›Issues›Fall 2017›Think You’ve Seen It All? When The Rules of Golf Make You Scratch Your Head

Think You’ve Seen It All? When The Rules of Golf Make You Scratch Your Head

By Jimmy Becker
October 23, 2017
9542
0
Share:

Golf seems like a simple sport. Hit a little ball many times and at some point, get the ball in the hole. Well, there are many situations during a round that will either make a golfer laugh, cry or sometimes both. For those of us who work in the industry, it is said that we have seen it all when it comes to Rules situations; but every once in a while, even we are surprised by a Rules scenario.

Flagstick (Un)Fun

The scene of this ruling was on the putting green of the third hole at The Golf Club of Rancho California in Murrieta during the 2016 SCGA Four-Ball Net Qualifier. A player was roughly 30 feet from the hole and left the putt two feet short. The player marked, lifted and cleaned his ball, and then replaced his ball properly under the Rules. Before he hit his next putt, he removed the flagstick and held onto it while he made his stroke, an act strangely permitted by the Rules. The next portion of the situation is more unfortunate. The ball missed the hole completely and somehow hit the flagstick the player was holding. Under Rule 17-3, the player was penalized 2 strokes and had to play the ball from where it came to rest after striking the flagstick.

Hat Time

At a collegiate event at El Caballero CC, our rules official was roving the back nine when a player on the 18th hole waved him over. She said she had hit her tee shot into the fairway bunker on the left side of the hole, then struck her second shot off the lip of the bunker. The ball flew back and hit the bill of her hat and came to rest back in the bunker. Under Rule 19-2, since the ball in motion was deflected by the player’s equipment (the hat on her head), she incurred a penalty of 1 stroke and had to play the ball from where it lay.

Smile! You’re On Camera

At the same collegiate event, a coach told our rules official that she saw another coach record a player’s swing with a smartphone, then show the recording to the player as they walked down the eighth hole. The coach did indeed tell us that she recorded her player’s swing and showed the player the video. Under Decision 14-3/16, there is no penalty to the player for the recording of her swing, however, there is a penalty for showing the player the swing in an advice capacity. Before 2016, this would have resulted in a disqualification. Now, however, under Rule 14-3 there would be a 2-stroke penalty assessed to the player.

Tees & String

At the 2012 SCGA Four-Ball Net Championship at Oak Valley GC, a player saw his fellow competitor make a stroke from the teeing ground. The tee the fellow-competitor used was tied to another tee with a string on it. When our rules official asked the competitor why he tied together two tees with string, he stated that he did not want to lose it or have it blow away. We’ll be honest, we had to call and ask the USGA for help on this one. After sending them a photo of the scenario, they confirmed what we thought. Under Rule 11-1, the player was disqualified for making a stroke at a ball on a non-conforming tee. Even though the tee by itself was conforming, when tied to another tee with string or other material, it was deemed to be non-conforming. The more unfortunate part is that given the format, Four-Ball Stroke Play, the breach of the Rule by the player dragged his partner down with him and he was also disqualified under Rule 31-7a.

Previous Article

Anecdotes from a New Golfer

Next Article

Foresight Sports Is Changing the Way We ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Jimmy Becker

Jimmy's career in golf administration began in 2004 as an intern with the SCGA and spent some time at the NCGA from 2005-2011. Since rejoining the SCGA in 2011, he helps administer SCGA, CGA and USGA qualifiers/championships, and is featured in the Rules Crew video series, teaching the Rules of Golf to SCGA members and its clubs. He is also in charge of the site procurement process for the Championships & Golf Operations department along with managing the exemption and Player of the Year programs. He has served as a Rules Official at numerous USGA National Championships and has achieved the highest level of rating on the PGA/USGA Rules Exam. A native Southern Californian, in his free time he enjoys hanging out with friends, playing sports and going to the beach.

Related articles More from author

  • Fall 2017SCGA Junior

    More Than a Golf Course

    October 23, 2017
    By Julia Pine
  • Know the RulesSummer 2021

    20 Things You Didn’t Know About Golf Equipment

    July 22, 2021
    By Jimmy Becker
  • Classic CourseFall 2017

    Sunnylands: A Hidden Political Golf Oasis

    October 23, 2017
    By Matt McKay
  • Know the RulesSummer 2023

    Beached, But Not Trapped: If an Entire Rule is Dedicated to one Area of the Course, you Know it Must ...

    July 21, 2023
    By Jimmy Becker
  • Know the RulesSpring 2024

    Penalties: Not Just For Football!

    May 6, 2024
    By Jimmy Becker
  • Fall 2017

    Par for the Course

    October 24, 2017
    By Ken Van Vechten

Recent Posts

  • Fall 2026FeaturedProfiles

    1,000 Courses and Counting

  • Fall 2026FeaturedModern Classic

    Picture Perfect

  • At The TurnFall 2026Featured

    An 8,000-Mile Journey

  • Club SpotlightFall 2026Featured

    The Queens of the LA Greens

  • At The TurnFall 2026Featured

    Robots on the Golf Course

Fall 2026FeaturedPublic Affairs

Newsom Signs Golf Bill Aimed at Illegitimate Tee Time Brokering

A Southland Scandal Resolves into a Statewide Solution The three seconds it took for Governor Newsom to affix his signature to AB 1954 (Ward; D-San Diego) brought to a successful ...
  • Working Bells

    By Adam Hawk
    November 3, 2026
  • Mesquite Rising

    By Joe Passov
    November 3, 2026
  • New Energy at Brookside GC

    By David Weiss
    November 3, 2026
  • Robots on the Golf Course

    By Tod Leonard
    November 3, 2026
© 2016 FORE Magazine About Us | Contact Us | Advertise