FORE Magazine

Top Menu

  • About Me
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Home

Main Menu

  • Current Issue
  • Profiles
  • Sustainability
  • Travel
  • 19th Hole
  • Classic Course
  • FORE Her
  • More
    • Know the Rules
    • Handicap Hints
    • SCGA Junior
    • Where Are They Now?
    • News
    • Public Affairs
  • scga.org
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login

logo

FORE Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Profiles
  • Sustainability
  • Travel
  • 19th Hole
  • Classic Course
  • FORE Her
  • More
    • Know the Rules
    • Handicap Hints
    • SCGA Junior
    • Where Are They Now?
    • News
    • Public Affairs
  • scga.org
Public AffairsWinter 2021
Home›Public Affairs›Dark Clouds on Muni Golf’s Horizon

Dark Clouds on Muni Golf’s Horizon

By Craig Kessler
January 15, 2021
1329
0
Share:

The SCGA opened last year with a bold announcement about 2020 being the year of municipal golf; the year we were going get down to focusing on certain challenges we defined as existential in the sector that has served for more than a century as the game’s growth engine.

A funny thing happened on the way to that year. As Lincoln reminded, we don’t control events; events control us. A hundred-year pandemic intervened, and 2020 became the year of coping with COVID.

We’re still coping, but the light at the end of this particular tunnel is getting brighter, and as it gets brighter and presages a return to some semblance of normality, we will get back to addressing those existential challenges. They didn’t go away; we merely put them on hold to address the immediate challenge of making golf’s case for being an activity almost uniquely suited to continuation during a pandemic.

COVID-19 has given golf an unexpected reprieve, and the industry has made much of it. But it has completely ignored another aspect of COVID-19 that is as consequential as the 26 percent bump that golf enjoyed over the last seven months of 2020: the hollowing out of the public sector.

A DISQUIETING TRUTH

Municipal budgets have been devastated. They are in free fall and promise to remain that way for some time. When Congress and the Federal Reserve passed out relief, they provided substantial support to virtually every sector and every constituency, but next to nothing to the nation’s state and local governments, which, unlike the national government, have to balance their budgets. Whether that indifference remains true with a new president and Congress is an open question, but we shouldn’t forget that the one sector that never recovered fully from the Great Recession is the public sector. It faces this downturn behind the rest.

Some of you will find that to be a long overdue haircut. Others will find it lamentable. Whatever your political beliefs, the following facts make it consequential for the California golf community. Twenty-two percent of the state’s golf stock is held by municipal governments. Roughly 40 percent of the game’s annual rounds are played on publicly owned courses, and more than 90 percent of the game’s growth programs are conducted on those courses. It’s going to be mighty tough to grow the game when the places where the industry has traditionally grown it are either gone or in distress.

WHEN CONGRESS AND THE FEDERAL RESERVE PASSED OUT RELIEF, THEY PROVIDED SUBSTANTIAL SUPPORT TO VIRTUALLY EVERY SECTOR AND EVERY CONSTITUENCY, BUT NEXT TO NOTHING TO THE NATION’S STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS…”

Those municipal courses in the state’s urban centers that turn profits are going to be vulnerable to having their net dollars diverted from planned capital projects to general fund coffers, in a mad dash to offset the drastic curtailments in tax receipts that are also the residue of COVID-19. This will create golf properties that are no longer capable of the reinvestments necessary to maintain their infrastructures in a manner conducive to attracting paying customers over the long run.

Those municipal courses that were marginal prior to COVID-19 aren’t going to survive once the COVID-19 party returns their tee sheets to some semblance of normality. Whatever appetite remained to subsidize their operations pre-COVID will be totally sated after COVID. We have already seen evidence of both disquieting phenomena.

NOWHERE TO GROW

In the short run, certain daily fee and non-equity clubs may benefit from newfound market share, but once the game is forced to again compete with other recreational and entertainment amenities, that benefit will begin to fade. And of course, if you live in the region’s biggest city (Los Angeles) you know that other than one daily-fee course on the northeastern edge of that city, all other golf courses are either private clubs or municipal courses. The daily-fee market was sacrificed to higher, better and much more lucrative land uses long ago.

The golf industry likes to talk the market-economy talk, but it tends to overlook the chapter on fungibility. Factories can cut production, lay off employees and take a number of steps short of closure. Small businesses like restaurants can close their doors and be replaced in very short order when markets pick back up; indeed, that’s a pretty good explanation of how much of Main Street in America operates.

But golf courses? There are no intermediary steps in a downturn. Once a golf course closes its doors —particularly in urban California, where most of the golfers are — it’s gone, never to be seen again.

As for planning and constructing new courses when the market goes back up, as it has over the last seven months? That’s a multiyear process that for the most part is onerously expensive, save for the kind of spectacular multi-course resort represented by a Bandon Dunes. And those courses don’t so much grow the game as provide a great golf vacation for the most avid and experienced golfers among us.

The pandemic that gave golf an unexpected boost has given the game the parallel challenge of a hollowed-out municipal stock. In truth, it has only accelerated a challenge long underway, one that the game has been slow to recognize. No, that understates it; the game has for the most part been blind to it, although it is beginning to dawn on at least some of the game’s normative leadership organizations that growing a game without places to grow it might be problematic.

Too little too late? Just in the nick of time? Somewhere in between? Some would say time will tell. Let me suggest that it will be the grit and determination of the greater golf community that will tell.

Previous Article

Farewell to Arms

Next Article

Ely’s Gift to Golf

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Craig Kessler

Craig came to the SCGA via the merger with the Public Links Golf Association (PLGA), where he served as Executive Director for 11 years and pioneered the development of the nation’s most active and accomplished advocacy component. He has been tasked with doing the same for the SCGA as its first Director of Governmental Affairs, albeit on a much larger stage. In addition to his current and previous job responsibilities, Craig has served as a USGA Committeemen continuously for 15 years, Chair of the Los Angeles Golf Advisory Commission, Chair of the Los Angeles County Golf Advisory Committee, Member of the City of Los Angeles’ Griffith Park Master Plan Board, Member of the Ventura Golf Advisory Group, Member of the Los Angeles County Junior Golf Foundation Board of Directors and Chair of the Los Angeles Junior Chamber of Commerce First Tee of Los Angeles Advisory Committee. In 2008 Craig was inducted into the Long Beach Golf Hall of Fame.

Related articles More from author

  • At The TurnWinter 2021

    A Look Back in Time: The LACC’s Hope-Ware Collection

    January 16, 2021
    By Judd Spicer
  • Public Affairs

    It’s All About The Water

    October 1, 2014
    By Craig Kessler
  • Public AffairsSpring 2019

    A Class Unto Itself: California’s Coachella Valley

    April 26, 2019
    By Craig Kessler
  • Golf GroupsWinter 2021

    Club Spotlight: Building a Golfing Family

    January 15, 2021
    By Scott Fluhler
  • water-crisis
    Public AffairsSummer 2016Sustainability

    Drought? Megadrought?: Where do we stand and what does it mean for Southern California’s golf courses?

    July 1, 2016
    By Craig Kessler
  • Public Affairs

    Governmental Affairs: Why We Do What We Do

    January 29, 2020
    By Craig Kessler

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Recent Posts

  • FeaturedFirst CutSpring 2022

    Nine is Fine (and here’s why): Get Creative when you Play and Find your New BFF

  • FeaturedHandicap HintsSpring 2022

    Keeping You Informed: GHIN Push Notifications on your Mobile Phones

  • FeaturedProfilesSpring 2022

    Bob Does Hollywood: The Hardest Working Man on Instagram Finds Gold in Golf

  • FeaturedGolf GroupsSpring 2022

    Wednesday Special: San Diego’s Hookers And Slicers Celebrate 50 Years

  • FeaturedSpring 2022The Podium

    Fan-Demonium: Up Close & Personal at WMPO’s 16th

FeaturedSpring 2022Travel

The Pubs of St Andrews

The challenge seemed daunting at first. On an eight-day trip to St Andrews, my job was to rate the pubs in this lively college town where golf began six centuries ...
  • Scotland Must-Plays & Hidden Gems: 10 Terrific Tracks that Prove the Old Course Isn’t the Only Game Around

    By Joe Passov
    April 21, 2022
  • Bob Does Hollywood: The Hardest Working Man on Instagram Finds Gold in Golf

    By Adam Hawk
    April 21, 2022
  • Not Your Father’s Game: With Two Facilities Newly Open and Callaway at the Helm, the Topgolf Explosion Comes to the Southland

    By Scott Kauffman
    April 21, 2022
  • The Provisional Ball: What? How? When?

    By Jimmy Becker
    April 21, 2022
© 2016 FORE Magazine About Us | Contact Us | Advertise